No.  I'm not a proponent of that; "If Tiger played then or Jack played now" stuff because, I can see a few things that would make a difference, both ways, but I'll talk about Tiger's disadvantages here:
1. When is it that The Greats rise to the highest degrees of their game. . .when they compete with the Greatest Competitors, true? I mean:
Jack had Lee et al,  All of your Great Spiritual leaders had their "Ceasers,"   Ali had Frazier-et al,   Zorro had that Police Sergent dude and Batman had The Riddler?  Poor Tiger- somebody will rise to the test, but soon...leave him, again

If it would be OK with his sponsors - Just for Huge Kicks, I'd love to see Tiger " Win One For The Gipper "  with Jack's old clubs !!  I'd love to see the ""Tradition"" haters'  be forced to plop their heads out of there, and get with the program- like the professionals that Jack and Tiger are

---

... he thinks in secrete and it comes to past, environment is but his looking glass -
"As A Man Thinketh"